Source-backed decision research

Explore how AAO evaluates evidence.

Search a substantial collection of case-specific reasoning, then narrow it by petition, field, legal issue, or date.

This expanded collection favors source-backed access over perfect automated classification. Fields, labels, summaries, and relevance may contain errors; records marked ‘broader context’ need extra care. Review the cited source before relying on any record. These appeals and motions do not show approval odds or denial rates, and are not legal advice or a prediction.

Clear filters

10,847 decisions / 36,849 findings

Showing 25911–25920

EB-1AEB-1A · MembershipNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Membership

membership in associations requiring outstanding achievements

Why AAO was not persuaded

The record lacked evidence of ASCAP's membership requirements, so the petitioner could not establish that the association requires outstanding achievements as judged by recognized national or international experts.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
The record lacked evidence of ASCAP's membership requirements, so the petitioner could not establish that the association requires outstanding achievements as judged by recognized national or international experts.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2010-04-08_01_B2203; source_row=11414
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · Commercial successNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Commercial success

commercial successes in the performing arts

Why AAO was not persuaded

The album credits for the gold and platinum recordings did not identify the petitioner, so the commercial success cannot be attributed to him. For other recordings, there was no evidence of actual sales or receipts. Simply showing participation in production does not meet the plain language requirement of commercial successes as shown by sales or receipts.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
The album credits for the gold and platinum recordings did not identify the petitioner, so the commercial success cannot be attributed to him. For other recordings, there was no evidence of actual sales or receipts. Simply showing participation in production does not meet the plain language requirement of commercial successes as shown by sales or receipts.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2010-04-08_01_B2203; source_row=11420
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · Final meritsNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Final merits

final merits determination

Why AAO was not persuaded

The AAO conducted the final merits determination sua sponte per the Kazarian two-step framework and found the totality of evidence insufficient. The petitioner worked in support roles for acclaimed artists, was not identified in album credits for gold and platinum recordings, and the commercial success of those recordings was attributable to the featured vocalists, not the petitioner.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
The AAO conducted the final merits determination sua sponte per the Kazarian two-step framework and found the totality of evidence insufficient. The petitioner worked in support roles for acclaimed artists, was not identified in album credits for gold and platinum recordings, and the commercial success of those recordings was attributable to the featured vocalists, not the petitioner.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2010-04-08_01_B2203; source_row=11421
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · Original contributionsNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Original contributions

original contributions of major significance

Why AAO was not persuaded

Although the petitioner received praise from collaborators, the letters do not specify what his original contributions were or how they were of major significance. There is no evidence demonstrating his influence on other musicians nationally or internationally or that the field has changed as a result of his work. Letters of support alone cannot form the cornerstone of a successful extraordinary ability claim.

Why this is useful

Distinguish original work from evidence that the contribution had major significance across the field.

View full reasoning +
Although the petitioner received praise from collaborators, the letters do not specify what his original contributions were or how they were of major significance. There is no evidence demonstrating his influence on other musicians nationally or internationally or that the field has changed as a result of his work. Letters of support alone cannot form the cornerstone of a successful extraordinary ability claim.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2010-04-08_01_B2203; source_row=11417
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · Published materialNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Published material

published material about the alien in major media

Why AAO was not persuaded

The articles were primarily about Nelly Furtado and her concert, not about the petitioner. Additionally, the petitioner failed to submit evidence establishing the websites as major media, and merely asserting on appeal that rolling stone and MTV are major media without documentary support is insufficient.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
The articles were primarily about Nelly Furtado and her concert, not about the petitioner. Additionally, the petitioner failed to submit evidence establishing the websites as major media, and merely asserting on appeal that rolling stone and MTV are major media without documentary support is insufficient.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2010-04-08_01_B2203; source_row=11415
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · JudgingNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Judging

judging the work of others

Why AAO was not persuaded

The judging activity occurred in 2008, after the August 15, 2007 petition filing date, and thus cannot be considered. Even if considered, evaluating a school's young students who have not yet begun working in the field does not meet the plain language requirement of judging the work of others in the same or allied field.

Why this is useful

See how invitations, completed assignments, and the nature of judging were documented and weighed.

View full reasoning +
The judging activity occurred in 2008, after the August 15, 2007 petition filing date, and thus cannot be considered. Even if considered, evaluating a school's young students who have not yet begun working in the field does not meet the plain language requirement of judging the work of others in the same or allied field.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2010-04-08_01_B2203; source_row=11416
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · AwardsNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Awards

prizes or awards

Why AAO was not persuaded

The plaques do not establish that the record sales were primarily attributable to the petitioner's work, and counsel expressly conceded the evidence is best classified as documentation of commercial success rather than nationally or internationally recognized prizes or awards.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
The plaques do not establish that the record sales were primarily attributable to the petitioner's work, and counsel expressly conceded the evidence is best classified as documentation of commercial success rather than nationally or internationally recognized prizes or awards.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2010-04-08_01_B2203; source_row=11413
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · Leading / critical roleNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Leading / critical role

leading or critical role for distinguished organizations

Why AAO was not persuaded

Being contracted to compose music for brief segments of television shows does not equate to a leading or critical role. There was no evidence differentiating the petitioner from other producers contributing to the music library, and the artist guitar endorsement with Godin did not establish a leading or critical role. The record also lacked evidence that these organizations had distinguished reputations.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
Being contracted to compose music for brief segments of television shows does not equate to a leading or critical role. There was no evidence differentiating the petitioner from other producers contributing to the music library, and the artist guitar endorsement with Godin did not establish a leading or critical role. The record also lacked evidence that these organizations had distinguished reputations.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2010-04-08_01_B2203; source_row=11418
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · High remunerationNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · High remuneration

high salary or significantly high remuneration

Why AAO was not persuaded

Most of the compensation evidence post-dated the petition filing date and could not be considered. The pre-filing evidence (the $3,000 contract and some ASCAP statements) lacked any basis for comparison to show the compensation was significantly high relative to others in the field.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
Most of the compensation evidence post-dated the petition filing date and could not be considered. The pre-filing evidence (the $3,000 contract and some ASCAP statements) lacked any basis for comparison to show the compensation was significantly high relative to others in the field.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2010-04-08_01_B2203; source_row=11419
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · Major awardNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Major award

one-time major internationally recognized award

Why AAO was not persuaded

The record lacked evidence of the selection process, judging criteria, or the caliber of competing candidates. The award was not shown to be globally recognized among the world's most renowned pianists.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
The record lacked evidence of the selection process, judging criteria, or the caliber of competing candidates. The award was not shown to be globally recognized among the world's most renowned pianists.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2010-04-08_04_B2203; source_row=11431
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
← Back to assessment