Source-backed decision research

Explore how AAO evaluates evidence.

Search a substantial collection of case-specific reasoning, then narrow it by petition, field, legal issue, or date.

This expanded collection favors source-backed access over perfect automated classification. Fields, labels, summaries, and relevance may contain errors; records marked ‘broader context’ need extra care. Review the cited source before relying on any record. These appeals and motions do not show approval odds or denial rates, and are not legal advice or a prediction.

Clear filters

10,847 decisions / 36,849 findings

Showing 28481–28490

EB-1AEB-1A · MembershipNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Membership

membership in associations requiring outstanding achievements

Why AAO was not persuaded

The Carteira de Trabalho is a worker classification system, not association membership. The coaching license requires experience and credentials, not outstanding achievements judged by national or international experts, and represents the lowest of four license levels. The Brazilian University national team did not qualify because it excluded professional athletes and was thus not sufficiently exclusive.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
The Carteira de Trabalho is a worker classification system, not association membership. The coaching license requires experience and credentials, not outstanding achievements judged by national or international experts, and represents the lowest of four license levels. The Brazilian University national team did not qualify because it excluded professional athletes and was thus not sufficiently exclusive.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-04-23_07_B2203; source_row=8757
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · Leading / critical roleNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Leading / critical role

leading or critical role for organizations or establishments with a distinguished reputation

Why AAO was not persuaded

The beneficiary did not demonstrate a leading or critical role as a player — he played only portions of games and no evidence was submitted about the teams' reputations. As a coach, the petitioner submitted no information about its organization's reputation and the beneficiary was one of fifteen coaches with no evidence distinguishing his role from others.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
The beneficiary did not demonstrate a leading or critical role as a player — he played only portions of games and no evidence was submitted about the teams' reputations. As a coach, the petitioner submitted no information about its organization's reputation and the beneficiary was one of fifteen coaches with no evidence distinguishing his role from others.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-04-23_07_B2203; source_row=8759
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · Original contributionsNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

OtherPhysician

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Original contributions

original contributions of major significance

Why AAO was not persuaded

Letters are praise from personal contacts and do not show original contributions of major significance to the entertainment industry beyond the beneficiary's employer; preexisting independent evidence of influence is lacking.

Why this is useful

Distinguish original work from evidence that the contribution had major significance across the field.

View full reasoning +
Letters are praise from personal contacts and do not show original contributions of major significance to the entertainment industry beyond the beneficiary's employer; preexisting independent evidence of influence is lacking.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-04-23_02_B2203; source_row=8723
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AComparable evidenceNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

OtherPhysician

Issue evaluated

Comparable evidence

comparable evidence under 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(4)

Why AAO was not persuaded

Comparable evidence is permitted only when the ten criteria do not readily apply to the occupation; petitioner offered no evidence that the criteria (e.g., high salary) are inapplicable to entertainment executives, and opinion letters are not 'comparable' to the strict documentation required.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
Comparable evidence is permitted only when the ten criteria do not readily apply to the occupation; petitioner offered no evidence that the criteria (e.g., high salary) are inapplicable to entertainment executives, and opinion letters are not 'comparable' to the strict documentation required.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-04-23_02_B2203; source_row=8726
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · Commercial successNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

OtherPhysician

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Commercial success

commercial successes in the performing arts

Why AAO was not persuaded

No evidence that Elan's success was attributable to the beneficiary or that he receives a substantial share of royalties; no audited sales documentation; reported company income does not show significant commercial success.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
No evidence that Elan's success was attributable to the beneficiary or that he receives a substantial share of royalties; no audited sales documentation; reported company income does not show significant commercial success.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-04-23_02_B2203; source_row=8725
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · Published materialNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

OtherPhysician

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Published material

published material about the alien

Why AAO was not persuaded

None of the submitted articles were about the beneficiary; they pre-dated his employment with the company and there is no evidence they appeared in major media.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
None of the submitted articles were about the beneficiary; they pre-dated his employment with the company and there is no evidence they appeared in major media.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-04-23_02_B2203; source_row=8722
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · Leading / critical roleNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

OtherPhysician

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Leading / critical role

leading or critical role for organizations with a distinguished reputation

Why AAO was not persuaded

Record lacks evidence that the employer has a distinguished reputation, and letters do not establish that the beneficiary's role was leading or critical compared to other executives or to the company's principals.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
Record lacks evidence that the employer has a distinguished reputation, and letters do not establish that the beneficiary's role was leading or critical compared to other executives or to the company's principals.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-04-23_02_B2203; source_row=8724
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · AwardsNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

OtherPhysician

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Awards

lesser nationally or internationally recognized prizes or awards

Why AAO was not persuaded

Certificates were issued after the filing date and cannot be considered; even on the merits, they are institutional recognition from a school with which the beneficiary had a direct business relationship, not nationally or internationally recognized awards.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
Certificates were issued after the filing date and cannot be considered; even on the merits, they are institutional recognition from a school with which the beneficiary had a direct business relationship, not nationally or internationally recognized awards.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-04-23_02_B2203; source_row=8721
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · Original contributionsNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Original contributions

original contributions of major significance

Why AAO was not persuaded

The newspaper article shows the petitioner co-introduced Kenshinkan Karate in Nepal after learning it from its Japanese creator, but this was not his own original contribution nor shown to be of major significance. Reference letters praise talent but do not identify original contributions or explain how they were of major significance.…

Why this is useful

Distinguish original work from evidence that the contribution had major significance across the field.

View full reasoning +
The newspaper article shows the petitioner co-introduced Kenshinkan Karate in Nepal after learning it from its Japanese creator, but this was not his own original contribution nor shown to be of major significance. Reference letters praise talent but do not identify original contributions or explain how they were of major significance. There is no evidence his training techniques were widely adopted or significantly influenced the sport nationally or internationally.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-04-23_05_B2203; source_row=8743
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · JudgingNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Judging

judging the work of others

Why AAO was not persuaded

The record lacks official rules showing that serving as a referee is tantamount to judging the work of others. Even if it were, there is no evidence about the names or expertise of athletes judged, the petitioner's assessments, or the level of acclaim associated with judging at these events. The affidavit-only claim for one tournament lacked corroborating documentary evidence.

Why this is useful

See how invitations, completed assignments, and the nature of judging were documented and weighed.

View full reasoning +
The record lacks official rules showing that serving as a referee is tantamount to judging the work of others. Even if it were, there is no evidence about the names or expertise of athletes judged, the petitioner's assessments, or the level of acclaim associated with judging at these events. The affidavit-only claim for one tournament lacked corroborating documentary evidence.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-04-23_05_B2203; source_row=8742
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
← Back to assessment