Source-backed decision research

Explore how AAO evaluates evidence.

Search a substantial collection of case-specific reasoning, then narrow it by petition, field, legal issue, or date.

This expanded collection favors source-backed access over perfect automated classification. Fields, labels, summaries, and relevance may contain errors; records marked ‘broader context’ need extra care. Review the cited source before relying on any record. These appeals and motions do not show approval odds or denial rates, and are not legal advice or a prediction.

Clear filters

10,847 decisions / 36,849 findings

Showing 28941–28950

EB-1AEB-1A · JudgingNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other104 papers

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Judging

judging the work of others

Why AAO was not persuaded

The petitioner submitted no documentation that he actually participated in the manuscript reviews, and the invitations did not indicate he was selected in a manner consistent with national or international acclaim. Being 'extremely knowledgeable' is not equivalent to being at the pinnacle of the field.

Why this is useful

See how invitations, completed assignments, and the nature of judging were documented and weighed.

View full reasoning +
The petitioner submitted no documentation that he actually participated in the manuscript reviews, and the invitations did not indicate he was selected in a manner consistent with national or international acclaim. Being 'extremely knowledgeable' is not equivalent to being at the pinnacle of the field.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-02-19_01_B2203; source_row=8285
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · Artistic displayNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Artistic display

display of work at artistic exhibitions or showcases

Why AAO was not persuaded

AAO agreed this criterion generally applies to visual arts but acknowledged comparable evidence could be considered. However, a general theatrical performance is not an exhibition or showcase of a particular artist's work, unlike an exclusive film festival. Broadway productions and Disney cruises provide commercial entertainment rather than exhibiting the work of an exclusive group of performers.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
AAO agreed this criterion generally applies to visual arts but acknowledged comparable evidence could be considered. However, a general theatrical performance is not an exhibition or showcase of a particular artist's work, unlike an exclusive film festival. Broadway productions and Disney cruises provide commercial entertainment rather than exhibiting the work of an exclusive group of performers.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-02-17_02_B2203; source_row=8265
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · Original contributionsNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Original contributions

original contributions of major significance

Why AAO was not persuaded

AAO found the letters praised the petitioner's talent but none identified an original contribution explaining how she impacted the field of acting as a whole. Contributing to the success of an individual show does not satisfy the plain language requirement of 'original' contributions of 'major significance' to the field.

Why this is useful

Distinguish original work from evidence that the contribution had major significance across the field.

View full reasoning +
AAO found the letters praised the petitioner's talent but none identified an original contribution explaining how she impacted the field of acting as a whole. Contributing to the success of an individual show does not satisfy the plain language requirement of 'original' contributions of 'major significance' to the field.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-02-17_02_B2203; source_row=8263
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · Commercial successNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Commercial success

commercial successes in the performing arts

Why AAO was not persuaded

AAO found the show was commercially successful prior to the petitioner's involvement and she does not appear in promotional materials such that she could be credited with the show's commercial success. Counsel never asserted this criterion.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
AAO found the show was commercially successful prior to the petitioner's involvement and she does not appear in promotional materials such that she could be credited with the show's commercial success. Counsel never asserted this criterion.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-02-17_02_B2203; source_row=8268
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · Leading / critical roleNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Leading / critical role

leading or critical role for distinguished organizations

Why AAO was not persuaded

AAO acknowledged the Broadway show's distinguished national reputation and recognized this was the petitioner's strongest evidence, but found the record did not consistently establish that her role was either leading or critical beyond the obvious need to fill every role in a musical. Disney cruise productions also lacked evidence of a nationally distinguished theatrical reputation.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
AAO acknowledged the Broadway show's distinguished national reputation and recognized this was the petitioner's strongest evidence, but found the record did not consistently establish that her role was either leading or critical beyond the obvious need to fill every role in a musical. Disney cruise productions also lacked evidence of a nationally distinguished theatrical reputation.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-02-17_02_B2203; source_row=8266
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · MembershipNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Membership

membership in associations requiring outstanding achievements

Why AAO was not persuaded

AAO found the associations function as professional unions that negotiate collective agreements and working conditions; the record contained no evidence that recognized national or international experts judge prospective members' achievements.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
AAO found the associations function as professional unions that negotiate collective agreements and working conditions; the record contained no evidence that recognized national or international experts judge prospective members' achievements.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-02-17_02_B2203; source_row=8260
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · High remunerationNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · High remuneration

high salary or remuneration

Why AAO was not persuaded

AAO found the petitioner submitted evidence of remuneration but did not establish how her income compares with the most renowned live theater performers nationwide, and counsel never asserted this criterion was met.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
AAO found the petitioner submitted evidence of remuneration but did not establish how her income compares with the most renowned live theater performers nationwide, and counsel never asserted this criterion was met.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-02-17_02_B2203; source_row=8267
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · Published materialNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Published material

published material about the alien in major media

Why AAO was not persuaded

None of the materials are 'about' the petitioner — he is named only in result charts or photo captions. The record also lacks evidence on the distribution or circulation of the publications to establish them as major media.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
None of the materials are 'about' the petitioner — he is named only in result charts or photo captions. The record also lacks evidence on the distribution or circulation of the publications to establish them as major media.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-02-17_03_B2203; source_row=8271
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AComparable evidenceNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

Comparable evidence

comparable evidence under 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(4)

Why AAO was not persuaded

Petitioner failed to explain how the regulatory criteria do not readily apply, and the evidence submitted (subjective letters, unverified attendance claims) is not comparable to the objective evidence required under the ten criteria.

Why this is useful

Use the reasoning to identify the specific factual or documentary gap AAO considered material.

View full reasoning +
Petitioner failed to explain how the regulatory criteria do not readily apply, and the evidence submitted (subjective letters, unverified attendance claims) is not comparable to the objective evidence required under the ten criteria.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-02-17_03_B2203; source_row=8273
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
EB-1AEB-1A · JudgingNot establishedAutomated extraction · broader context

Case facts

Other

Issue evaluated

EB-1A · Judging

participation as a judge of the work of others

Why AAO was not persuaded

The regulation requires evidence the alien has actually participated as a judge, not eligibility to judge. Counsel abandoned this argument on motion.

Why this is useful

See how invitations, completed assignments, and the nature of judging were documented and weighed.

View full reasoning +
The regulation requires evidence the alien has actually participated as a judge, not eligibility to judge. Counsel abandoned this argument on motion.
Exact record locator: findings_long.parquet filename_stem=2009-02-17_03_B2203; source_row=8272
Revision: 081d2cac29dcadfec88fdd675d7a0c4294d72b3c
Open source dataset ↗
← Back to assessment